Top Boston Criminal Defense Lawyer

PPP and EIDL Fraud Charges in Massachusetts

The Pandemic Is Over. The Prosecutions Are Not.

Four new federal wire fraud indictments over PPP and EIDL applications show where the government is still looking, and what anyone who took pandemic relief should understand now.

More than six years after the first Paycheck Protection Program loans went out, who is still answering for them? On October 22, 2026, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Massachusetts gave a blunt answer: four more people, each indicted on a single count of wire fraud.

What the government alleges

According to the charging documents as described by the U.S. Attorney’s Office, Jonathan Arroyo, 43, of Boston; Daquan Dooley, 37, of Attleboro; Demetrous Thomas, 36, of Acushnet; and Gianni Williams Johnson, 28, of Boston, each face one count of wire fraud. Arroyo, Dooley and Thomas were arrested and appeared in federal court in Boston. Williams Johnson is detained on an unrelated matter in Suffolk Superior Court and is expected to appear in federal court.

The government alleges that Arroyo, Thomas, and Williams Johnson each submitted a PPP application on their own behalf, claiming a business that had suffered pandemic harm, and supported it with tax return information that was never filed with the IRS. Each received a forgivable loan of more than $20,000. Prosecutors allege that none of the three owned a business and that bank records show none of the money went to payroll. As to Dooley, the government alleges an EIDL application that claimed a business and led to a $10,000 advance, a grant that did not have to be repaid, and that bank records show thousands of dollars spent at a casino and none on business expenses.

Wire fraud carries up to 20 years in prison, three years of supervised release, and a fine of $250,000 or twice the gross gain or loss, whichever is greater. These are allegations. Each defendant is presumed innocent unless and until the government proves guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Three things this announcement tells us

Time is not a defense

In 2022, Congress extended the limitations period to ten years for many pandemic loan fraud offenses. A loan funded in 2021 can still be charged well into the next decade, and the government has shown it intends to use that time.

“These cases do not age out quietly. A borrower who took relief money in 2021 should assume the government can still look at that application years from now, and that it has the patience to do it.”

– Vikas S. Dhar, Principal and Cofounder, Dhar Law, LLP

The enforcement machinery is built and staffed

The District of Massachusetts created a Benefit & Voter Fraud Team in March 2026 and runs a public tip line for suspected benefit fraud. In April 2026 the Department of Justice created a National Fraud Enforcement Division. This latest case was announced alongside Homeland Security Investigations, the U.S. Postal Inspection Service and the Department of Labor’s Office of Inspector General. That is three investigative agencies in one case about loan applications.

“Pandemic fraud used to look like a backlog. It now looks like a priority, with dedicated teams, multiple agencies and a hotline. That raises the odds that an old application gets a second look.”

– Vikas S. Dhar, Principal and Cofounder, Dhar Law, LLP

These cases are built from paper

The allegations here turn on comparison: what the application said, what the IRS has on file, and where the money went. Nobody needs a confession to make that comparison.

“Long before anyone is arrested, prosecutors can set an application beside the IRS record and the bank statements and see whether they match. Anyone who applied for relief should assume that comparison can be run.”

– Paul Andrews, Attorney, Dhar Law, LLP

Where these cases are actually fought

A false statement on an application is not the end of the analysis. Wire fraud requires a scheme to defraud and the intent to carry it out. That is where experienced defense counsel focuses first.

Who prepared the application matters, because many were completed with help from accountants, loan brokers, lenders or friends. What the applicant knew and approved matters. So does materiality, meaning whether a statement actually bore on the lender’s decision. And how the money was spent matters in a particular way: it is evidence the government will use to argue intent, but it is not the offense itself, and it can cut in more than one direction.

“An inaccurate application is not automatically a crime. The question is intent. In most of these cases the real contest is over who prepared the paperwork, what the applicant actually knew, and what the government can prove about both.”

– Paul Andrews, Attorney, Dhar Law, LLP

Sentencing is its own fight. The loss amount drives the Guidelines range, and the government will also pursue restitution and forfeiture. Early work on loss, role and personal history can change the outcome by years, not months.

The consequences reach past the sentence

A fraud conviction can carry restitution, forfeiture, exclusion from government programs, and the loss of professional licenses. For noncitizens, including lawful permanent residents, a fraud offense involving a loss to the victim over $10,000 can qualify as an aggravated felony under federal immigration law, triggering mandatory removal consequences and closing most forms of relief.

“For a noncitizen, the fraud count is only part of the exposure. A loss figure above $10,000 can change what a conviction means for immigration, and it can change everything about how the case should be resolved. We evaluate that before we discuss any plea.”

– Vikas S. Dhar, Principal and Cofounder, Dhar Law, LLP

If you applied for pandemic relief

Most borrowers will never face scrutiny, and an honest mistake is not a federal crime. But if an agent calls, leaves a card, or serves a subpoena or grand jury summons, the rules change. Do not give a statement without counsel. Do not delete, alter or “clean up” any record, and do not file amended returns or correct an application on impulse, because well meant fixes can be read as obstruction or as an admission. Gather your documents and leave them as they are. Then call a lawyer.

Counsel who act before charges are filed have options that disappear after an indictment. A lawyer can sometimes open a dialogue with prosecutors, shape what the government learns and when, and work toward an outcome that never involves a courtroom. Our team includes former federal and state prosecutors who have seen how these cases are built from the inside, and we defend as one team.

“If an agent leaves a card, the next call you make should be to a lawyer, not back to the agent. What you say in the first conversation can shape the entire case.”

– Vikas S. Dhar, Principal and Cofounder, Dhar Law, LLP

The question that matters

A relief application ran a few pages and ended with a signature. The consequences of a false one can run twenty years. Between the day the money arrived and the day an agent shows up, there is a window. You can use it deliberately, with a plan, or let it close by default. The people in Massachusetts who learned about their cases this week did not get to choose.

If you have questions about a PPP or EIDL application, a letter from an agency, or contact from federal agents, call Dhar Law at 617-880-6155 or contact us online to schedule a consultation. We will tell you where you stand.

Source: U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of Massachusetts, “Four Men Charged with Pandemic Relief Fraud,” October 22, 2026

This post is for general information, is attorney advertising, and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship. The charges discussed are allegations, and the defendants are presumed innocent.

Arrested?

Have you or a family member been charged or arrested? It’s important not to make mistakes early on in your case. Download our PDF on the top 3 things to do to help your defense or if you have been arrested by the State Police or FBI or you are the subject of an FBI Arrest Warrant.

Get Dhar Law

Heading up the firm, Vikas Dhar is widely recognized as a leader in the New England legal community. An accomplished business litigator and a “Top 40 Under 40” criminal defense attorney, he has also been honored as a New England Super Lawyer/Rising Star in the area of White-Collar Criminal Defense for each of the past six years by Boston Magazine.

Bad things can unexpectedly happen to good people since not every choice they make can be blessed with moral clarity. You didn’t expect this rainy day, but we have the biggest umbrella. Call us – we will get through this together.

— Vikas Dhar
Abstract gradientAbstract gradientAbstract gradientAbstract gradient